In 2026, test policies are bifurcated. Some highly selective schools require SAT/ACT scores. Some make them optional. The strategic framework for each is different — and confusing them costs admits.
Test-required schools (2026 cycle)
- MIT — required, used heavily in admissions
- Caltech — required
- Georgetown — required (one of the few selective privates that returned to required)
- Most public flagships (UNC, UVA, GA Tech, Texas, Florida, Tennessee) — required
- Service academies (West Point, Annapolis, Air Force) — required
- All military programs and ROTC programs — typically required
Test-optional schools (2026 cycle)
- Most Ivies (Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Brown, Columbia, Penn, Cornell — except Dartmouth which returned to required)
- Most highly selective private schools (Stanford, Duke, Northwestern, Vanderbilt, Washington University, Notre Dame, Tufts, etc.)
- Most LACs (Williams, Amherst, Pomona, Swarthmore, Bowdoin, Carleton, etc.)
- Many state flagships (Michigan, Virginia, Berkeley, UCLA, etc.)
Strategy at test-required schools
If your target school requires tests, your strategy is straightforward:
- Take the SAT and ACT, submit your stronger score.
- Aim for at or above the school's 50th percentile of admits per published CDS data.
- If you're significantly below, prep harder or reconsider whether this school is realistic.
- Multiple test attempts are standard. Schools see your highest score (Score Choice) at most schools.
Strategy at test-optional schools
Strategy is more nuanced:
When to submit your score
- Score is at or above the school's 50th percentile of admits (per CDS).
- Score is well above the school's 25th percentile (in the upper third of admit range).
- Submitting strengthens the rest of your application (e.g., your GPA is good but not exceptional, and the score adds context).
When to NOT submit
- Score is below the school's 25th percentile of admits.
- Score is between the 25th and 50th percentile and the rest of your application is strong.
- You don't have a score (or score is older than the school's testing window).
Calibration: what the data shows
At top private test-optional schools, 50-65% of admits typically submitted scores. The mean of submitted scores is meaningfully above the published 25th percentile because students self-select to submit only when their scores are strong.
If you submit a score, you're competing with the applicants who submitted scores — a group with higher mean scores than the published 25th percentile. So 'at the school's 25th percentile' may be below the submitted-score median. Calibrate accordingly.
Strategy at test-blind schools (UC system, CSU)
UC system, CSU, and a few others (Reed, Hampshire) are test-blind — they will not consider scores even if you submit them. Your application is evaluated entirely on other factors. Don't submit scores; they won't be looked at.
How to research a school's exact policy
- Check the school's admissions website current cycle policy.
- Read the school's Common Data Set Section C9 — admit rate breakdown by test submission.
- Cross-reference with last year's data on Niche or per-school admissions blogs.
- When in doubt, contact the admissions office to confirm.
What test-optional doesn't mean
- It doesn't mean tests don't matter. They matter when strong; they're just not required.
- It doesn't mean students who submit scores have an advantage. They do, when scores are strong.
- It doesn't mean you can submit any score. Submit only at-or-above the 50th percentile.
- It doesn't mean rest of application matters less. It matters more — there's no test score 'fallback' for weak applications.
Common mistakes
- Submitting weak scores 'just to show I tried.' Hurts more than helps.
- Not submitting strong scores 'because the school is test-optional.' Wastes a strength.
- Skipping test prep entirely at test-optional schools. You may want a strong score later.
- Assuming all test-optional schools have the same approach. They don't — verify per school.
- Confusing test-optional with test-blind. Different policies.
The bottom line
Test-required schools: take the test, submit your strongest score. Test-optional schools: submit when score is strong (at or above 50th percentile of admits), don't submit when weak (below 25th). Test-blind schools: don't submit at all — they won't consider it.
Strategy isn't binary. It's calibrated to your specific score and each school's specific policy. The right framework for you depends on your school list and your test scores. AdmitPath helps you make these calls.